India defends sterilisation of women

India defends sterilisation of women

Friday, November 14, 2014 9:29 am


Women taking part in India's sterilisation programme. AFP

Women taking part in India’s sterilisation programme. AFP

BILASPUR (AFP) – India has defended a state-run programme that offers poor women cash incentives to get sterilised after the deaths of 13 women triggered international condemnation.

Health Minister Jagat Prakash Nadda said it was a “misconception” that India set sterilisation targets for local authorities in an effort to control the growth of its billion-plus population.

“It is a target-free, promotional and a demand-driven programme,” a government statement quoting Nadda as saying late Thursday.

Indian authorities have come under criticism from rights groups and the United Nations after a mass sterilisation camp in central Chhattisgarh state led to the deaths of 12 women. Another woman died after a second session, held on Monday.

Dozens more are still in hospital after Saturday’s camp, when a single surgeon operated on 83 women in just five hours — spending an average of less than four minutes on each patient.

The doctor, who was detained on Wednesday, has accused the government of making him a scapegoat for the controversial sterilisation scheme, which pays impoverished women 1,400 rupees ($23) to go under the knife.

Human Rights Watch has said health workers in India are coercing women into getting sterilised, under pressure to meet informal targets.

Although India scrapped national sterilisation targets in 1996, the advocacy group said local health workers were still given quotas for the procedure and their jobs were on the line if they failed to meet them.

The United Nations has called for all those responsible for the deaths to be held accountable and said that contraceptive choices should be made “without any forms of incentives”.

“Any laws, procedures or protocols that might have allowed or contributed to the deaths and other human rights violations should be reformed or changed to prevent recurrences,” it said in a statement on Thursday.

– Drugs seized –

Chhattisgarh’s chief minister has sacked the surgeon who conducted the operations and the chief medical officer who supervised them.

The state has launched a judicial enquiry, and is also testing the drugs that the women were given after the surgery.

“The seized drugs have been sent for examination,” Chhattisgarh Chief Minister Raman Singh said.

“If there is anything wrong with the drugs, we will act against the companies, manufacturer, purchaser and the medical team,” he added.

The state government has banned five drugs used at the camp pending investigations, including an anaesthetic and a pain killer.


Join The Conversation

One Comment

  • Shima K Gyoh says:

    Many acts of negligence and inhumane practice of medicine are
    responsible for this tragedy. First, the doctor was involved in serious
    malpractice:

    He seemed to be oblivious of the universally accepted fact that the
    professional expertise and safety of the operation is a responsibility of the
    doctor, and that includes the safety of the operating room and the drugs given
    to the patient. People who are not ready to accept this responsibility have no
    business being a medical doctor. When asked why he operated under unhygienic
    conditions, the doctor claimed that that it was the duty of the government to keep the
    hospital clean! Further, he dissociated himself quality from of drugs given to
    the patients. Then his actions are reminiscent of a factory worker fixing his
    own nut on a conveyor belt of a manufacturing outfit, with no indication that
    these are conscious human beings that need tender care and reassurance and must
    each be given individual attention, and their dignity respected. In this day
    and age, taking pride in speed of operation with no etiquette and respect to
    the dignity of each individual patient is highly unethical. It is not
    sufficient to dismiss this doctor; he should be tried for professional misconduct
    and barred from further practice. He should go work in one of India’s car
    manufacturing companies, standing in one place and fixing exhausts like a robot
    on cars as they move past him on the conveyor belt.

    I am not impressed by the attitude of the Indian Minister of Health who
    went on wild defence of his government (like the average Nigerian Minister) as
    if the story were not true. I expect much better response from government
    officials when such a disgraceful happening in their country breaks out into
    nasty world news. His comment has no relevance to the serious humanitarian
    tragedy that occurred under his watch. I say, no wonder it happened, and if he
    continues with this attitude, it will continue to happen.

    Shame on the health workers who took monetary reward to press these poor
    women to come for such ghastly experience, and greater shame on those who
    further short-changed the poor women out the paltry sum they were supposed to
    get for their pains. An inquiry is needed to identify and punish them.

    I dare say Nigeria cannot be as bad as this!

    Shima K Gyoh

    Makurdi, Benue State

  • What do you think?

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.