Abia governorship: Why Justice Abang’s judgement cannot stand – Court of Appeal

Abia governorship: Why Justice Abang’s judgement cannot stand – Court of Appeal

Friday, August 19, 2016 12:01 am

Governor Ikpeazu: Victorious

Governor Ikpeazu: Victorious

The Court of Apeal in Abuja on Thursday upheld the election of Dr Okezie Ikpeazu as governor of Abia.


Justice Morenikeji Ogunwumiju-led other four justices of the appellate court unanimously set aside the June 27 decision of Federal High Court which sacked Ikpeazu from office.


The others judges are Justice Abubakar Yahaya, Justice Philomena Ekpe, Justice Ibrahim Bdliya and Justice Saidu Hussaini.


The court delivered judgments on six appeals filed by interested parties in the governorship tussle.


Ikpeazu had challenged his removal on account of an allegation of falsification of his tax papers.


The governor joined Mr Uche Ogah, the judgment creditor, PDP, INEC and Mr Friday Nwosu as the respondents.


She also held that it was wrong for the plaintiff to have approached the trial court with an originating summons without affidavit evidence.


“The appeal has sought the leave of court to decide whether the court was right to have based its decision on suit that was brought by way of originating procedure.


“As for us here, the suit should have been by way of a writ of summons as it required affidavit evidence to proof a criminal allegation of tax falsification.


“The trial court was hostile and pre-judicial as the judge shifted the burden of proof from the plaintiffs to the defendant (Ikpeazu),’’ she said.


Ogunwumiju further held that no cause of action was established when the suit was instituted.


She said Nwosu, one of the candidates at the December, 2014 primaries of the party had filed his suit before Ikpeazu’s name was submitted to INEC as PDP governorship Candidate.


“In fact the allegation should have come before the governorship election being a pre-election matter.


“Looking at the substance of the case, the appellant was not to blame for any error noticed in the tax certificate submitted to election body.


“The information has not established any grounds to show that the governor used it to gain advantage on the rest contestants,’’ she said.


Ogunwumiju said: “the worrisome aspect of the trial decision was that the judge imported words into the PDP guidelines to gain appropriate grip on the appellant’’.


“It is my opinion that Justice Okon Abang sat in his Chamber to speculate what Ikpeazu earned while he served as a Civil Servant in Abia State.


“The annoying part is that, he went further to bar the Director of Abia State Revenue Authority, Mr James Okogie, from giving evidence, describing the move as an afterthought.


“This can simply be described as an abortion of justice as the governor was not given fair hearing to defending himself,’’ Ogunwumiju held.


She said: “in the light of the above, the decision of the trial court dated June 27 is set aside along with the consequential order’’


“By this, we mean Ikpeazu is returned as governor of Abia State,’’ she held.


NAN reports that Ikpeazu awarded N100,000 each to be paid Nwosu and Ogah respectively.


Also delivering judgment on the governor’s appeal on the jurisdiction of the trial while a notice of appeal was served it, Justice Philomina Ekpe, held that the jurisdiction of the lower court sized immediately the appeal was entered.


“Justice Abang failed to act in line with the doctrine of “stari decisis” .


“He was compelled to transfer the record of the case to the Court of Appeal for determination the moment he was notified of the pending appeal.


The judge had on July 8 insisted that he had jurisdiction to hear a motion for stay of execution of his earlier judgments delivered even after the appeals against the judgments had been entered.


Ekpe also held that the trial court wrongly interpreted the provisions of Order 4(10) and (11) of the Court of Appeal rules in that circumstance.


“The trial judge should have been aware that he lacked jurisdictions to interpret the provisions of the Court of Appeal being the rules of a superior court,’’ she said.


NAN reports that the other appeals filed by Obasi Mba, Nwosu, Chukwuemaka Mba were all decided in favour of the governor with N100, 000 each to also be paid by them.


NAN report that the PDP’s appeal was decided in favour of the party with Ikpeazu a benefiting party.

Meanwhile, Gov. Ikpeazu of Abia has expressed joy over his victory at the Court of Appeal, Abuja, saying that he had been spurred to do more.


Ikpeazu, who said this while addressing newsmen at the Government House, Umuahia, said the victory reinvigorated him to serve the people with greater zeal.


He thanked God for the victory, saying that he dedicated the victory to the people of the state.


He also expressed gratitude to the judiciary which, he said, had proved to be the hope of the common man.


“Without the judiciary of this country, what would have been the fate of the poor son of a teacher, who became governor at the mercy of God and people of Abia.


“The news before of us is a wonderful one and we are grateful to God for what He has done that our mandate has once again been affirmed by the Court of Appeal.


“This to us is a victory for the common people of Abia, who voted massively for us in 2015,” he said.


He said that with the judgment he had been “re-invigorated in our service to Ndi-Abia without letting them down”.


Ikpeazu thanked the people for their support and steadfastness in prayer for his victory and urged them not to rest on their oars.


The governor further charged the media to ensure that all arms of government work in consonance to promote the ideals of democracy.


“The gains this country has achieved in terms of our democratic experience is too much for us to toy with.


“We can recover from our economic problems but we may never recover if we drawback on our gains in democratic governance,” he said.


News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) reports that the Court of Appeal affirmed the election of Ikpeazu and quashed the June 26 judgment of Justice Okon Abang of the Abuja High Court.


Abang had ordered Ikpeazu to vacate office for Dr. Uche Ogah, who challenged Ikpeazu’s eligibility to contest the 2015 governorship election as the flag bearer of the Peoples’ Democratic Party (PDP).


Following the judgment of the High Court for the immediate inauguration of Ogah as Abia governor, the Independent National Electoral Commission, issued him with the Certificate of Return.


Meanwhile, members of the Board of Trustees of PDP, led by their chairman, Sen. Walid Jibrin, who were at the Government House at the time the news of the judgment filtered in, congratulated the governor on his victory.

Join The Conversation

What do you think?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.